Over-reaching claims, #StillATeenager, and Twitterpation

Hanging Out, Messing Around and Geeking Out

The video below was a bit of an awakener to me, mainly because it highlighted that I am incredibly similar to our target audience (i.e. high school students) in terms of my online activity. YouTube Preview Image

While I may not be quite as “friendship driven”, (and hopefully a lot less drama-prone!), I really felt like “Messing Around” and “Geeking Out” portion really applied to me.  I’m sure this is not unique, but getting lost in gaming, web tutorials, using torrents to find media otherwise not available (especially outside of the US)–all of this is par for the course for me.  I was not terribly surprised by this, as students have commented to me that, “You know about that site?!”.  Yes, little Johnny–just because I don’t Vine doesn’t mean I can’t Torrent!


We’ve arrived at the most exciting part of this week’s readings and assignments:  Building your Twitter PLN.  I’ve been totally “twitterpated” (as @Chezvivien predicted) as I finally committed to giving Tweets a proper chance.  I had messed around with Twitter in the past, but had not really delved in and tried to make it work for me.  Now I get it.

Screen Shot 2015-02-16 at 5.14.12 AM

TweetDeck allows me to follow hashtags that I am interested in.

Most importantly, I discovered TweetDeck.  The power of TweetDeck is that it allows you to follow hashtags, instead of only following people.  There’s nothing wrong with following people, of course, but humans have this nasty thing called “free will”, where they post things that they want to post, regardless of whether the all-important-I want to see them!  Enter TweetDeck:  Nobody is going to use the hashtag #chemchat to deliver a “goodnight everyone” message.  I won’t find pictures of someone’s oh-so-cute baby with the #coetail marker.

I also sent a probe out to what I would consider an “old-school” PLN–my National Science Teachers Association listserve.  This is a hugely helpful resource, and when I asked “Who is using Twitter?”, I immediately found another 15 very tech-friendly science teachers.  Perfect!

Blooms Digital Taxonomy

It took me a while to really understand what this article was attempting to accomplish, and I am still a bit confused as to how useful it is to me personally.   It appears to be attempting to rank various types of ‘digital activity’ (for lack of a better term) based on the level of thinking associated with that activity–an idea that I believe might be fundamentally flawed.

Screen Shot 2015-02-15 at 8.14.52 AM

Can we really rank methods of communication?

At it’s core was a claim that certain stages of thinking are lower-order than others, and that as teachers, our job is to increase the amount of time spent in the higher-order thinking;  this seems to be unanimously agreed upon.  It is far superior to understand why the volume of a gas increases with temperature, instead of memorizing that the volume of a gas increases with temperature.  It is true that not all learning can be considered equal.

However, I believe the article went too far in it’s claims.  In the central diagram, where the digital taxonomy’s key terms were broken down (thesauras-style), a “Communication Spectrum” is presented.   Many methods of communication are presented (as well as some more general terms, such as Debating or Questioning), and given rank in order of lower to higher order.   It seems to me that claiming that instant-messaging and emailing are somehow by-nature to be lower-order than replying or collaborating is far too general.  I have written and received plenty of very high-level emails, and witnessed some incredibly low-level collaborative exercises.  I believe we get a bit giddy about anything where more than one person is involved. Throwing out email as a lower-order communication method is unnecessary and inaccurate.

I do believe that this list of communication methods was useful for me in my planning, as it will (hopefully) serve as inspiration:  How can I incorporate blogging into this unit?  Could my students use animation to help comprehend these concepts?  I wonder if a collaborative animation project would be useful?  In the dreaded and upcoming Internal Assessment, I am thinking about asking students to make a blog post in which they state their research question and invite feedback from their peers (i.e. commenting).  I could give the other students a rubric or checklist, which details what makes a good research question, and they could use this to comment on each other’s blog.  It would be a welcome change of pace for them–instead of only receiving feedback from me, they would hear it from their peers.

You may also like...

17 Responses

  1. Hi Ryan,

    Like you, I also used to have a Twitter account, but couldn’t really get into the whole Twitter scene. After much debating, I decided to log back into my account, and had to reset the password because I had no clue what it was; it had been a while since I was even lurking on Twitter. I am starting to see now how using it professionally really makes sense. And TweetDeck sounds like something I would give a try. One of the reasons I was originally turned off by Twitter was that it took a while to find useful information because I had to sift through lots of irrelevant tweets before I found something useful. It looks like TweetDeck does just that. Searching by hashtag will definitely provide more focused search results. Thanks for sharing this!

  2. Paul Browne says:

    Ryan, thanks for sharing the suggestion that Tweetdeck could be very useful. You are spot on. Not sure which part of the digital spectrum I am on in terms of being “with it” or not, but the ease of use of Tweetdeck has already lead me in to new territory in terms of making connections. There is a digitally connected world that is running ahead of me with colleagues, IB workshop leaders and social campaigns all out there. One thing I have found is that I sometimes feel a slight tinge of loneliness in the Coetail world in terms of teachers in HS science- are we out there? However, I can see already that Tweetdeck is an enabler for making connections to new people but also very useful to re-establish links to people I already know on a professional level (HS physics teachers!) In terms of sharing something relevant from my old (but not well used) twitter account yet newly established Tweetdeck connection, I found (on a HS physics teacher’s tweet): link to teachthought.com. Links into to some of your discussion about communication and questioning. Some very simple, yet effective diagrams that will help the assignment hit the higher end of Bloom…… In fact, I shall just retweet that (via Tweetdeck of course) to my legions of followers right now.

  3. Vivian says:

    Hi Ryan

    By the looks of it, you’re definitely “twitterpated”! You definitely have more hashtags on your tweet deck than I do! I always have to smile when I see any of your tweets or Tanya LeClair’s, as I know I helped the two of you get started with twitter. Believe it or not, I mentor a number of Coetailers by following them quite closely, emailing occasionally, and commenting on their blogposts. Some of them haven’t waded into the Twittersphere, despite my urging to them that they need to give it a proper “go” before giving up. 🙂 So, I feel kind of chuffed to see you and Tanya start and flourish and all I did was tweet you guys a few links lol.

    I’m glad to see you enjoying your Coetail journey and letting the courses and the PLN broaden your horizons.



  4. Now the requirements for all tasks are being increased. To get help in solving them you can turn to our service to get highly qualified help in solving homework from professionals in order to get more time for yourself. We offer complete writing, editing and research assistance for your college needs. No lower payment or in advance payment. Do not pay to anybody on craigslist before they reveal the work.

  5. Assignment help will be there for you and with you from your early school years till you earn your PhD. Assignmenthelp.us , with their years of expertise in providing law assignment help, can easily provide you with all the help with law assignment whenever you require.

  6. essay help says:

    The essay writing services mainly aim to help the concerned students with the solutions to the assignments that might help them to secure better grades and in turn improve their academic career. These custom essay writing services tend to claim that the solutions that they provide o the clients would fetch them better grades against the given assignment.

  7. Did you know the number of courses offered in the Universities here? The number is over 30,000. Is not it amazing? From science to business, everything and every subject is taught here.

  8. Here, you will get to know some of the tips about what hooks to choose and how you can implement them. Research paper help providers know all the knitty-gritty of such works and they can help you write the best one. Here are the types of hooks that you can use in your essay or research papers.

  9. Thanks for giving this type of platform that helps to find the all the function of the control panel which get more useful.

  10. Persuing MBA from international universities, here we provide best MBA Help at affordable prices. Buy Term Papers for your MBA online and get higher grades in your academics.

    Did you know the number of courses offered in the Universities here? The number is over 30,000. Is not it amazing? From science to business, everything and every subject is taught here.

  11. I can’t help thinking that asserting that texting and messaging are some way or another commonly to be bring down request than answering or teaming up is dreadfully broad.

  12. Those students who are searching for assignment help services in USA can contact with our experts. We are best services providers over the country. Our experts are available round the clock, students can contact them at any time.

  13. The primary use of an IP address Admin is to allow network administrators and users to connect to a router for functions such as changing internet settings, conducting administrative functions and customizing security settings and more

  14. Essay Writer says:

    Such a nice blog post on this topic. I Adam Hebrew from Aberdeen, UK. Adam Hebrew, an ex-visiting professor of a reputed UK university, has been a part of Myassignmenthelp.co.uk for the past 6 years. He completed his doctoral degree from Oxford University. He is one of our most eminent essay writers.

  15. Students could often find it tough to write their academic tasks. It could lead to them not getting desired grades in the academics. Opting for our Online Assignment Help could be ideal for such students and they can get a complete assignment solution from us.

  16. All Assignment Help reviews sites. We strongly urge you to check our entire website once and we will assure you will find this review website very useful. Our hard work will be rewarded if students like you will appreciate our effort and spread the message about this site with your class-fellows and friends.

  17. smith says:

    Those who are searching over internet cdr writing services can contact with us now. We are the best assignment writing service provider in melbourne, Australia. Our Academic assignment writers available 24*7 hours for the students, if you really want to need assignment help online at cheapest price meet cdr assignment help at sample assignment and get high distinction grades.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *